Going Out of Business courtesy of reinvented via Flickr

I remember several years ago reading an article reporting on the results of a study showing that consumers will put up with poor customer service almost as much as they will good customer service. I was appalled at that assertion. Why in the world would people put up with bad service? Surely good service wins the day every time. Turns out – no, it doesn’t.

After years of watching people in retail settings, I’ve discovered that they actually will put up with bad customer service. We’ve all seen restaurants with terrible service, but doing a booming business because they’re trendy. What people won’t put up with is inconsistent service. Good one time and bad the next will quickly lose you customers. Customers might deal with it for a short while, but not long.

I used to be a manager at a fast food restaurant. I remember once deciding that I wanted to deliver service so good for customers that they would want to tip our workers (voluntarily), just as they do at a full-service restaurant. For weeks I busted my tail, delivering great service at the counters and even going to table offering to get refills and take trays. People were impressed with the service, but I didn’t see them coming back more than usual. Now, I’m older and wiser and realize that what I was doing was terrible. I was probably inadvertantly hurting the restaurant. Why? Customers weren’t getting consistent service. They were used to a certain level of service, and I was confusing them with something different. Worse yet, a customer could come get great service from me one evening, then come that for lunch the next day and get mediocre service. They couldn’t know what to expect.

I still believe that good service is better and than bad service. All things being equal, I think good service wins the day. However, inconsistent service will kill your business faster than either.